History records the insidious machinations of European Imperialism in Africa, known as the Scramble for Africa, or the New Imperialism era, from 1881 to 1914. This infamous period saw Europe exert oppressive control over almost 90% of Africa, where only Ethiopia and Liberia remained independent. Driven by covetous ambitions for natural resources, national prestige, rivalry, and religious zeal, European powers wreaked havoc on African lands, leaving an indelible scar on the continent’s history.
In a cruel irony, the Berlin Conference of 1884, ostensibly designed to regulate European colonisation and trade in Africa, became the grim starting point for the partitioning of Africa. As the centuries turned, so did European dominance transition from “informal imperialism,” which wielded military influence and economic power, to colonial imperialism, characterized by brutal direct rule.
Despite technological advances that facilitated European expansion, the Scramble for Africa was fuelled by a desperate quest for economic, political, and social dominance. Driven by a burgeoning trade deficit, European ruling elites saw in Africa a fertile ground for the exploitation of resources to create a trade surplus. The strategic rivalry among European powers played out brutally on African soil, shaping the continent’s destiny in unsettling ways.
Today, this history remains an ugly blot on Europe’s moral standing, starkly contradicting its claim to being a champion of human rights. The disturbing events unfolding in Melilla, Spain, involving the deaths of dozens of African migrants, refugees, and asylum seekers, lay bare the hypocritical stance of European powers, who still appear unwilling to respect the basic rights of African people.
In June 2022, an alarming incident involving the deaths of at least 37 Africans, most of Sudanese and South Sudanese descent, exposed the deadly violence meted out to people of African and Middle Eastern descent at the EU borders. Rather than being a safe heaven, these borders have become grim symbols of racial exclusion and brutality. Despite interventions from the United Nations, there is scant evidence of accountability for the violence in Melilla, with both Spanish and Moroccan governments seemingly reluctant to conduct thorough investigations and provide reparations to the victims and their families.
The lack of meaningful accountability for these incidents is a chilling reminder of the past when European powers escaped unscathed for their brutalities in Africa. It’s a damning testament to the fact that Europe, despite professing commitments to human rights, is yet to come to terms with the historical injustices it inflicted upon Africa.
In this context, Europe’s moral authority to pontificate for Africa comes under critical scrutiny. It is not enough for Europe to pay lip service to human rights while ignoring the historical injustices inflicted on Africa or turning a blind eye to the ongoing atrocities at its borders. A deep, sincere reckoning with its past is a prerequisite for Europe to claim moral authority. This involves not just acknowledgement and remorse for the past but also concrete actions that embody its commitment to justice, equality, and human rights.
Until then, Europe’s pontification for Africa remains an exercise in futility, and its moral claims lack credibility. True morality isn’t derived from power or dominance; it’s rooted in accountability, justice, and a genuine respect for the dignity and rights of all people. It’s time for Europe to reflect on this truth and take meaningful actions to make amends for its historical injustices. The actions and attitudes of the present and future must redeem the wrongs of the past. Only then can Europe truly claim the moral authority to pontificate for Africa.
When we view the contemporary relations between Europe and Africa, we find a historical hangover of the past imperialism and colonial exploitation. In this era of proclaimed equality and human rights, Europe, burdened by its past, lacks the moral authority to pontificate to Africa.
The reverberations of the economic exploitation during the colonial era are still evident today in the underdeveloped economies of many African countries. Yet, Europe continues to employ policies that prioritize its interests over Africa’s, often dictating the terms of trade agreements that reinforce old patterns of economic dependency and exploitation. Europe’s past exploitation and ongoing economic practices make it morally untenable for it to lecture Africa on economic development and governance.
Read Also: Britain, And Her Joy In Profiting From Stolen Artifacts
Politically, the imperial past still haunts the relations between Europe and Africa. Europe’s disregard for indigenous governance systems during colonial times contributed to the political instability many African nations struggle with today. It’s therefore ironic when European nations critique the political systems in Africa, systems their past actions helped shape. Can Europe, with its colonial past marred by destabilising interventions, honestly chastise Africa about political instability or governance?
Culturally, the suppression of African identities and the imposition of European norms during the colonial period left deep scars. Europe cannot ignore this past when promoting its values as universal standards. The cultural homogenisation attempted in the colonial period is seen as an oppressive move, not a benevolent one. Hence, Europe, carrying this baggage, finds itself in an awkward position to pontificate on cultural or human rights issues.
Modern happenings, such as the incident in Melilla, Spain, only serve to highlight Europe’s questionable position. The violent encounters leading to the tragic deaths of migrants of African descent echo the disregard for African lives that characterised the colonial period. Yet, months later, there is still no concrete accountability. Such incidents starkly contrast with the human rights ideals Europe proclaims, further undermining its moral authority.
Europe’s imperial past and its current dealings with Africa, unfortunately, indicate a lack of moral rectitude to lecture Africa. If Europe genuinely aims for a relationship of equals with Africa, it needs to reckon with its imperial past, rectify present wrongs, and create truly equitable policies that benefit both continents. Only then can it start to regain the moral high ground to advocate for mutual growth and development.
In conclusion, the impact of European imperialism on Africa has been profound and its remnants are still evident in the continent’s economic, political, and cultural landscape. The historical context of this exploitation brings into question Europe’s moral position to guide or critique Africa today, an argument bolstered by some unsettling facts and figures.
Economically, Africa continues to grapple with the challenges posed by the exploitative models introduced during the colonial period. As of 2022, Africa’s share in world trade was a mere 2.7%, indicative of the unequal global trade structures that perpetuate Africa’s economic vulnerabilities. Moreover, as highlighted by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Africa remains a net exporter of capital to the world, with illicit capital flight estimated at about $50 billion annually.
Politically, many African countries have struggled with instability and conflict, much of which can be traced back to the arbitrary boundaries and governance systems imposed by the colonisers. For instance, the African Union reported in 2022 that about 14 of its 55 member states were dealing with armed conflict, indicating the persistent challenges of post-colonial state-building and peace-building.
Culturally, the legacy of forced assimilation and cultural erasure remains vivid. Over 2,000 distinct languages are spoken in Africa, yet former colonial languages – English, French, Portuguese, and Spanish – continue to dominate in official and educational settings, a testament to the enduring cultural imperialism.
Moreover, incidents such as the Melilla border event in Spain, where African migrants were met with violence, illustrate Europe’s continuing struggle to uphold the human rights ideals it espouses. This incident, among others, underscores the moral ambiguities in Europe’s relations with Africa, posing a challenge to its claim to moral leadership.
All these factors necessitate a thorough reckoning with history and a reassessment of the dynamics in the Europe-Africa relationship. To foster a relationship of equals, it is crucial for Europe to acknowledge its imperial past, its impact, and rectify its present dealings with Africa. By doing so, a path towards mutual respect, understanding, and equitable development could be charted, eventually rebuilding the moral authority Europe seeks.
